Dog Food Reviews

With the guidance of a clinical veterinarian, Pet Food Sherpa has developed a unique pet food rating system that evaluates foods using key metrics like ingredient quality, recall history, price, and more.

By applying this system to our extensive pet food database, we’ve analyzed more than 10,000 ingredients and thousands of recipes.

To date, we’ve reviewed over 5,000 pet foods from more than 500 brands. Our in-depth brand reviews give you the information you need to make an informed decision about what goes in your dog’s bowl.

At a glance, you’ll get vital details about the brand, including where the company is headquartered, where its foods are made, how many times it’s been recalled, and which types of products it offers.

Click on a specific product for nutritional insights about ingredient quality, allergens, protein content, and more.

Ready to explore the database? Sort reviews alphabetically, by score (sorted from highest rating to lowest), or by price (sorted lowest to highest). If you have a specific brand in mind, type its name into the search tool.

Addiction

Overall Score
48%
Addiction Read Review

Adirondack

Overall Score
63%
Adirondack Read Review

Almo Nature

Overall Score
72%
Almo Nature Read Review

ALPO

Overall Score
69%
ALPO Read Review

Annamaet

Overall Score
66%
Annamaet Read Review

Atta Boy

Overall Score
65%
Atta Boy Read Review

Authority

Overall Score
71%
Authority Read Review

AvoDerm

Overall Score
69%
AvoDerm Read Review

Bench & Field

Overall Score
67%
Bench & Field Read Review

Bil-Jac

Overall Score
68%
Bil-Jac Read Review

BIXBI

Overall Score
63%
BIXBI Read Review

Black Gold

Overall Score
67%
Black Gold Read Review

Blackwood

Overall Score
69%
Blackwood Read Review

Blue Buffalo

Overall Score
66%
Blue Buffalo Read Review

Boss Dog

Overall Score
68%
Boss Dog Read Review

Bravo!

Overall Score
45%
Bravo! Read Review

Brutus Broth

Overall Score
59%
Brutus Broth Read Review

Buckley

Overall Score
69%
Buckley Read Review

Canada Fresh

Overall Score
73%
Canada Fresh Read Review

CANIDAE

Overall Score
69%
CANIDAE Read Review

Canisource

Overall Score
68%
Canisource Read Review

Caru

Overall Score
65%
Caru Read Review

Cesar

Overall Score
67%
Cesar Read Review

Chicken Soup

Overall Score
71%
Chicken Soup Read Review

Cloud Star

Overall Score
66%
Cloud Star Read Review

Crave

Overall Score
74%
Crave Read Review

Diamond

Overall Score
70%
Diamond Read Review

Dog Chow

Overall Score
70%
Dog Chow Read Review

Dog Whisperer

Overall Score
75%
Dog Whisperer Read Review

Dogswell

Overall Score
73%
Dogswell Read Review

Dr. Harvey's

Overall Score
52%
Dr. Harvey's Read Review

Dr. Mercola

Overall Score
56%
Dr. Mercola Read Review

Dr. Pol

Overall Score
69%
Dr. Pol Read Review

Dr. Tim's

Overall Score
69%
Dr. Tim's Read Review

Eagle Pack

Overall Score
66%
Eagle Pack Read Review

Eukanuba

Overall Score
58%
Eukanuba Read Review

Evanger's

Overall Score
58%
Evanger's Read Review

Evolve

Overall Score
54%
Evolve Read Review

Farmina

Overall Score
69%
Farmina Read Review

FirstMate

Overall Score
71%
FirstMate Read Review

FLAVORS

Overall Score
69%
FLAVORS Read Review

Forza10

Overall Score
63%
Forza10 Read Review

Freely

Overall Score
68%
Freely Read Review

Gather

Overall Score
62%
Gather Read Review

Gentle Giants

Overall Score
69%
Gentle Giants Read Review

Go!

Overall Score
68%
Go! Read Review

Gravy Train

Overall Score
66%
Gravy Train Read Review

Halo

Overall Score
61%
Halo Read Review

Healthy Dogma

Overall Score
51%
Healthy Dogma Read Review

Herbsmith

Overall Score
64%
Herbsmith Read Review

HI-TOR

Overall Score
69%
HI-TOR Read Review

Horizon

Overall Score
66%
Horizon Read Review

Hound & Gatos

Overall Score
72%
Hound & Gatos Read Review

Iams

Overall Score
57%
Iams Read Review

Inaba

Overall Score
52%
Inaba Read Review

Inception

Overall Score
70%
Inception Read Review

Instinct

Overall Score
65%
Instinct Read Review

Inukshuk

Overall Score
72%
Inukshuk Read Review

Jiminy's

Overall Score
61%
Jiminy's Read Review

Joy

Overall Score
68%
Joy Read Review

K9 Natural

Overall Score
55%
K9 Natural Read Review

KASIKS

Overall Score
73%
KASIKS Read Review

Kinetic

Overall Score
70%
Kinetic Read Review

Lafeber

Overall Score
55%
Lafeber Read Review

Lotus

Overall Score
68%
Lotus Read Review

Mazuri

Overall Score
62%
Mazuri Read Review

Meat Mates

Overall Score
75%
Meat Mates Read Review

MeatMe

Overall Score
65%
MeatMe Read Review

Merrick

Overall Score
65%
Merrick Read Review

Mixables

Overall Score
71%
Mixables Read Review

Moist & Meaty

Overall Score
67%
Moist & Meaty Read Review

Nandi

Overall Score
65%
Nandi Read Review

Newman's Own

Overall Score
73%
Newman's Own Read Review

Now Fresh

Overall Score
62%
Now Fresh Read Review

Nulo

Overall Score
71%
Nulo Read Review

Nutrisca

Overall Score
56%
Nutrisca Read Review

Nutro

Overall Score
67%
Nutro Read Review

Olewo

Overall Score
48%
Olewo Read Review

OrgaNOMics

Overall Score
74%
OrgaNOMics Read Review

ORIJEN

Overall Score
70%
ORIJEN Read Review

Party Animal

Overall Score
74%
Party Animal Read Review

Pedigree

Overall Score
59%
Pedigree Read Review

Perfectus

Overall Score
64%
Perfectus Read Review

PET TAO

Overall Score
63%
PET TAO Read Review

Pet Wellbeing

Overall Score
71%
Pet Wellbeing Read Review

PetGuard

Overall Score
62%
PetGuard Read Review

PetKind

Overall Score
70%
PetKind Read Review

Pinnacle

Overall Score
58%
Pinnacle Read Review

Plato

Overall Score
66%
Plato Read Review

Primal

Overall Score
54%
Primal Read Review

Pro Pac

Overall Score
54%
Pro Pac Read Review

Project Paws

Overall Score
58%
Project Paws Read Review

Puppy Chow

Overall Score
72%
Puppy Chow Read Review

Purina Bella

Overall Score
72%
Purina Bella Read Review

Purina Beyond

Overall Score
67%
Purina Beyond Read Review

Purina ONE

Overall Score
71%
Purina ONE Read Review

Purpose

Overall Score
65%
Purpose Read Review

Realtree

Overall Score
72%
Realtree Read Review

Redbarn

Overall Score
54%
Redbarn Read Review

Royal Canin

Overall Score
65%
Royal Canin Read Review

Side By Side

Overall Score
60%
Side By Side Read Review

Sojos

Overall Score
62%
Sojos Read Review

Solid Gold

Overall Score
69%
Solid Gold Read Review

SPORTMiX

Overall Score
53%
SPORTMiX Read Review

Spot Farms

Overall Score
68%
Spot Farms Read Review

Strongpoint

Overall Score
71%
Strongpoint Read Review

Tender & True

Overall Score
67%
Tender & True Read Review

Tiki Dog

Overall Score
69%
Tiki Dog Read Review

Total Feeds

Overall Score
70%
Total Feeds Read Review

Triumph

Overall Score
63%
Triumph Read Review

TruDog

Overall Score
57%
TruDog Read Review

True Chews

Overall Score
65%
True Chews Read Review

Tylee's

Overall Score
73%
Tylee's Read Review

Under the Sun

Overall Score
74%
Under the Sun Read Review

V-Dog

Overall Score
61%
V-Dog Read Review

VICTOR

Overall Score
69%
VICTOR Read Review

Walk About

Overall Score
67%
Walk About Read Review

Wellness

Overall Score
62%
Wellness Read Review

Weruva

Overall Score
73%
Weruva Read Review

Wet Noses

Overall Score
62%
Wet Noses Read Review

Whole Life

Overall Score
62%
Whole Life Read Review

Wild Earth

Overall Score
65%
Wild Earth Read Review

Wishbone

Overall Score
63%
Wishbone Read Review

Wysong

Overall Score
70%
Wysong Read Review

Zeal Canada

Overall Score
72%
Zeal Canada Read Review

Zignature

Overall Score
70%
Zignature Read Review

Ziwi

Overall Score
75%
Ziwi Read Review